Date:Reviewed in the United States on June 4, 2018

Review:Not sure if you've noticed but you can't find these in the drug stores anymore. The new ones are weird. They go on way too dark, are not smooth to apply and the smudge thingy is rubber instead of spongy like this one. Oh and most of them are like a twistable crayon which I did not find to be a plus. This is the good old one you've used for years so if you're unhappy with the eyeliner pencils you're finding in the stores now, you'll be happy to be back with this one. Don't know why they tried to change it. It didn't need any improvement. Color was as expected and it applies wonderfully and lasts all day. This is definitely one of those things where "Don't fix it if it ain't broke" applies. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on January 29, 2019

Review:Love this pencil! It's very pigmented and it stayed on all day. Perfect for eyebrows and lip liner too. Here is a pic of me wearing it on my brows, lips, and eyes. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on December 8, 2019

Review:I have used this product for at least 20 or so years. I blend it in with my Prestige Liquid Eyeliner, also a Black/Brown Color. At this price I’m buying 2 at a time. It’s a great product, and is also waterproof. I’m enclosing a selfie that was taken last year in natural lighting, so you can see my eye makeup. By the way, I sometimes blend this in also with my eyeshadow. It’s a staple of my eye makeup, and I always have at least 3 or 4. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 31, 2017

Review:I have been using this charcoal eyeliner for over 10 years. I have tried others but I always come back to it. It's a great alternative for black if you want something less harsh and it has a tiny bit of shimmer in it which brightens the eyes. I also use black mascara and it makes a great combo for daily wear. It will last all day and does not smudge. Highly recommend. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on March 9, 2016

Review:I've been spoiled with my Urban Decay liner pencils which glide on like butter. I decided to try this to see if a less expensive product would give equally good results, and the answer (at least regarding CoverGirl) is no. This pencil is actually somewhat painful to apply because it doesn't draw on easily and requires several heavy passes to get a decent looking line. But once it's on, it's not going anywhere... I have to scrub at my eyes with makeup remover to get this stuff off. My eyes do not thank me. I haven't tried the blending feature at all, so I can't comment on that aspect. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 3, 2018

Review:I know this is an eyeliner pencil but I actually use it to fill in my eye brows. Having a light skin tone and light eyebrows it’s difficult to find the right shade that doesn’t look too dark, too red, or too green. This Works perfectly with the color of my brows. It doesn’t smudge off during the day and looks way more natural than the eyebrow pencil shades typically do. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on February 2, 2018

Review:This is my favorite pencil for defining my eyebrows. It's hard to find this color on the shelf, so I am very happy to be able to order it at Amazon. It is on my Subscribe and Save List. Easy to sharpen without breaking the point, which was hard on previous pencils I have tried. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on March 15, 2018

Review:I've been having a tough time finding eyeliner pencils in the drug store lately. They sell the type that you have to twist in order to use. They are a thin stick and they break easily. Turned to Amazon to find an eyeliner pencil. This one does the trick. Color is as expected. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 19, 2017

Review:Arrived well before date expected. Product fine just how it was when I brought it in UK years ago. Read more

Date:Reviewed in Mexico on August 26, 2020

Review:Negro intenso, es el único que me ha gustado de corre un poco con el tiempo o calor pero es de los mejores Read more

Date:Reviewed in Mexico on August 24, 2020

Review:El delineador llego bien en buenas condiciones, pero se corre mucho después de aplicarlo y casi no pinta bien, se ve muy tenue el negro hay que pasarlo varias veces para agarrar un tono mas fuerte. No lo recomiendo Read more

Date:Reviewed in Canada on May 3, 2020

Review:This is a great product. Classic, affordable, and actually is nice and dark and smudgy. Perfect. Read more

Date:Reviewed in Mexico on November 9, 2019

Review:La esponja que tiene ayuda mucho a dar un bonito acabado, no aguanta mucho el calor, pero aún así lo recomiendo, lo volveré a comprar, llegó en un día Read more