Date:Reviewed in the United States on December 28, 2019

Review:PROS: COLOR/PIGMENT - I am in my late sixties and still like DARK eyeliner, but not harsh. THAT'S difficult to find. What I LOVE about this eyeliner is that I can SMUDGE it when I first put it on (and I just do a thin line and just on UPPER eyelid). It's dark, but not harsh looking. STAYING POWER - For my upper lid, this works just fine. No raccoon eyes. But then I don't use a ton and I intentionally smudge it. I CANNOT speak for how it would be on the undereye along the water line. GLIDING POWER! - THIS WAS HUGE FOR ME. Having lids getting close to seven decades old, there is some wrinkling and they're just more sensitive. I had a pencil that was supposed to be really easy and supposed to glide on, NOT SO MUCH. This goes on as smoothly as I can expect from a pencil. (and I STILL like pencils for ease in putting on and staying power over liquids or gels) COST - IF you have priced eyeliner lately, NOT inexpensive and if you look at reviews as I DO, you can see where often three times more in price doesn't mean it's any better! This gives me WHAT I want for a great price. CONS: I have a steady hand and having been using eyeliner for decades, so don't have a problem. IF your lids are really wrinkled, your skin really thin/sensitive, your hand not overly steady, I would suggest a powder. I have used this on occasion, more to lightly touch up brows, but it's GENTLE. HARD to draw a thin line though. L'Oréal Paris Infallible Smokissime Powder Eyeliner Pen . Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on September 14, 2020

Review:Scrolling through Amazon in search of a waterproof eyeliner I came across this little gem. Why did I stop and open the ad? Because of the price and It claimed to be waterproof. Okay, fine I’ll try it. It’s only $4.00. It arrived in good condition and is as described in the ad. While it is waterproof it isn’t all that smudge proof. My allergies drive me bananas at times and leave me rubbing my eyes like a sleepy baby. My eyes can go from glamorous to raccoon in 3.2 seconds if I don’t use the right liner/mascara. My thoughts: It’s definitely worth the $4.00. It’s waterproof. Which is the whole point. So long as I don’t go to town rubbing my eyes like a nut, my makeup stays put just fine and looks great all day. That’s another thing, it doesn’t have to reapplied through the day and doesn’t leave that line in any creases or fine lines around the eyes that some eye products do. It does have a sharpener so you can come at your eyes with sharper lines, but honestly, it's more for definition and blending than for harsh or defined lines. It’s great for the smoky look and blends well with the included blender tip or your finger. I will be buying this product again. Note: Using this product 5-6 days a week it lasted 8 weeks before running out. If you found this review helpful, please consider hitting the “helpful” button to let me know. Thanks and happy shopping! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 1, 2017

Review:Rimmel Exaggerate waterproof eyeliner is my favorite eyeliner. It is reasonably priced. It is easy to apply and stays on better than most other eyeliners I have used. I like that it never needs sharpening. However, if you wish to keep the tip in a precise point, a small, built-in sharpener is included. (I myself do not sharpen mine.) Despite it being called waterproof, I don’t find it to be. First off, I can wash it off while showering without using any type of makeup remover. Also, my eyes tend to water occasionally and I usually end up wiping some of it off when drying my eyes. Lastly, some of it does end up in the lid crease at times. But I would rather have that problem than have to struggle to remove the eyeliner (and lose an eyelash or two) as what happens with some of the other waterproof eye products. Would recommend. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on December 26, 2018

Review:Reading eye-liner reviews, it seems that the same eyeliner performs very differently on different people, even aside from how they want to use it. I have somewhat dry skin, and this Rimmel eyeliner goes on easily, although with a somewhat uneven line. It stays soft long enough to smoothly blend and shade the line then stays in place all day, even beneath the lower lid. No walking dead vampire eyes here! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 5, 2019

Review:I bought this product [first] on a clearance sale at Walmart. I had never seen "copper" eye shadow before, so I thought I would try it. As a senior, I don't want to look ridiculous, but I found the color to highlight my hazel eyes amazingly! It goes on smoothly and doesn't pull on a wrinkly eyelid. It has just enough gloss to be soft looking without being too shiny. I wanted more to keep on-hand, but since it had been on clearance, I assumed I wouldn't be able to find it again in a store. I went to Amazon and found exactly what I was looking for at a reasonable price! Very happy. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on March 19, 2017

Review:I've used a lot of eyeliner and a lot of cheap eyeliner and this is by far the best I've used, glides on very nice and has a dramatic effect. Stays in place amazingly and I used it on my water line and it made it thru a day of hiking,swimming and showering before I wiped it off... It only sunk down a little but I would just wipe that away and it would still look like I was wearing eye liner. Wonderful product, will be purchasing again and you should too! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on July 23, 2016

Review:I love this product!! I needed a eyeliner that stays on all day and is also easy to draw with. I do not have any eyelashes so this is imperative for me. I have used many others. Spent a fortune on different liners and this, for me, is the BEST! I have worn this in the heat and it still stayed on! Nice dark color and you have time to smudge it if you want, before it dries. I will definitely be buying this again and again. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on March 17, 2018

Review:FALSE ADVERTISEMENT!! NOT WATERPROOF!!! It has sandy texture! Smears and smudges and gave me an allergic reaction! My eyelids swell within a few hours after apply it! No do not buy this product!! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 23, 2020

Review:I have used this for a long time now as it seems to stay on longer than normal eyeliner! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on June 7, 2018

Review:I have used this eyeliner many times before with no issues however I ordered 2 eyeliner and when you use them they are crumbling so are almost impossible to use, so disappointed. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on February 18, 2020

Review:Excellent Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on July 16, 2019

Review:Love the colour Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 13, 2021

Review:Line underneath my eyes ...very good doesn't run or smudge ...been using this product for years ...no complaints Read more