Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 25, 2018

Review:Likes: Product line is great Dislikes: there is no protective seal. Item came unwrapped. I'm not going to use a product that I know isn't supposed to come the way it did. Just terrible. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on December 12, 2016

Review:The application is easy because it twists up, and glides on well. But it leaves a lot of black residue around my eyes as the day goes on. I find myself constantly wiping under my eyes to get rid of the darkness left by this eyeliner. (I only apply on the top lashes). I've had better luck with low-cost eyeliners like wet and wild. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on September 11, 2018

Review:I am a make up artist and always trying new things. This deserves a one star. The tip continuously broke off. I probably only used it five times before all the product had broken off. Plus this photo is a little deceiving. You are only purchasing one pencil yet two are pictured. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on October 5, 2018

Review:I have been wearing this same eyeliner for over eight years now. It is the only pencil eyeliner with smudger combo that I have ever had that wears like a true waterproof eyeliner. I have an eye that does not have a tear duct system so it constantly waters, and this is the only eyeliner that I have ever had that lasts throughout the day!!! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on May 25, 2019

Review:So I've been using another brand for about 2 years and it came up on my Amazon as a suggestion. Read the comments and thought what the heck, I'll try. Amazing! I put it on early in the morning, attended a brunch, then a wedding, then the reception and checked it throughout the day and it was just as if had just applied. Excellent product! and great price. You will not be disappointed. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on May 3, 2019

Review:I love the color and how dark it goes on. I purchased the black one and my husband loved it on me it comes out so beautifully dark, the only problem I have is that it doesn’t last very long I tried to use it under my eyes and all I can say is raccoon! But it does well on the top as long is you prime it, make sure you don’t touch your eyes or sweat because it will smudge, it’s not waterproof, it goes on smoothly. I have oily lids so it may not do too well if I’m outside for very long so I give this a 4 out of 5 being that I love the color, I wish it lasted longer throughout the day. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on November 27, 2018

Review:I love Rimmel Exaggerate eyeliners. I apply in the morning, put some shadow or powder on over to set it and it's good all day long. This particular color (Earl Grey) was darker than I'd been expecting/hoping for, but when I put it on I just loved it. It's a good dark grey and has very tiny, eye flattering sparkles in it. The sparkles were an unexpected bonus! Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United States on March 1, 2019

Review:Like it, and cheaper than Sephora. This is cheaper than the comparable product from Sephora (brand) and is basically the same thing. Actually...less greasy even. I have hooded eyes and it doesn't transfer from my lid to my crease "overhang" is a crease "overhang" the anatomical term? Well it is now. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on June 12, 2018

Review:If you just want a soft easy to apply eye liner then this is lovely and smooth too! I suffer from watery eyes now and need waterproof eye make up - and this definitely isnt that! Within a couple of minutes it had ran! I had to dab it away - so it had gone. Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 8, 2019

Review:I often buy these items so am totally pleased with the product however the packaging was disgusting. There were 2 eye liners in a box measuring 9 inches x 7 inches x 4 inches and it was also stuffed with that blown up plastic that looks like armbands. What a terrible waste of the Earth's resources - shocking! Please pass this message to the seller/packer Read more

Date:Reviewed in the United Kingdom on December 16, 2018

Review:This eyeliner is overall decent but there’s few flaws. If you’re looking to do a nice neat cat wing then this isn’t the eyeliner for you, there’s no fine point and wears down very quickly. It’s also not exactly waterproof, it’s more water resistant so if you’re caught or splashed with a little water there’s a very big chance of it turning your eyes into panda bear eyes. Also if you’re a beginner at eyeliner and try and re draw over the area to fill in and darken in colour it becomes lumpy. However there are benefits such as its ease of drawing on, doesn’t drag on the eyes and is smooth. Read more

Date:Reviewed in Italy on March 2, 2019

Review:È la mia matita per gli occhi da anni! Iniziamo con la grande comodità che non deve essere temperata, per cui la punta rimane ben definita e non si rovina. Il tratto è preciso, la matita efficace poiché lascia un segno forte e definito con un solo passaggio sia all'interno che sulla palpebra. Utile pennello per sfumare all'altra estremità. Approfittando di uno sconto interessante ne ho prese due e sono arrivata ben confenzionate separatamente ed imballate prima in una bustina di plastica e poi nella scatola. Arrivate integre e puntuali. Super consigliata Read more

Date:Reviewed in France on September 11, 2018

Review:Je me mets toujours un trait de crayon à l'intérieur de la paupière inférieure et quand j'ai vu que ce crayon était waterproof j'ai sauté sur l'aubaine. Bien mal m'en a pris ! Déjà, le crayon est arrivé sans emballage, non scellé .... C'est plus que moyen pour un produit cosmétique ! De plus, au bout de 4 heures, comme un crayon classique, il a commencé à s'estomper. Donc aucun intérêt dans ce crayon vu qu'il ne tient pas plus longtemps. Déçue du produit, je ne le rachèterai pas. Read more